Reporting and identification

An overview is presented below of the types of artefact reports I offer and the typical information presented in each of the different reporting formats. These reports follow the Chartered Institute for Archaeology‘s (CIfA) specialist reporting types (see more information below about Standards and Guidance) and include assessment and analysis reports. These reporting terms are particularly relevant for the work that I undertake for commercial archaeology projects.

If you are not sure what type of report would best suit the needs of your project, I will be happy to discuss this with you in order to find the best fit. No one project is the same as another, so there are ways to tailor the approach to studying and reporting on your finds to ensure you are presented with the information you need. 

Standards and Guidance

My work follows current professional guidance and standards. I adhere to Chartered Institute for Archaeologists’ (CIfA) Standard and guidance for the collection, documentation, conservation and research of archaeological materials (2014), and their Toolkit for Specialist Reporting Guidelines V1.1 (2021). The latter defines three specialist reporting types: descriptive reports (Type 1), appraisal/assessment reports (Type 2) and full analysis/publication reports (Type 3). You can find out more information about these different types of reports below. I also work in line with Historic England, the Portable Antiquity Scheme and ALGAO guidelines as well First Aid for Finds. Where appropriate, ALGAO’s Scotland Before The Museum guidelines will be employed.

Where available, relevant Research Frameworks (e.g. the Scottish Archaeological Research Framework (ScARF); Yorkshire Archaeological Research Framework etc.) will be consulted and referenced.   

Finds identification

Basic artefact identification is a service that I offer. However, please be aware that this information is presented in a more informal way and, as a result, does not conform to professional specialist reporting guidelines or standards.

Descriptive reports (Type 1)

Descriptive reports are typically undertaken only on small assemblages of low archaeological significance and act as a record of the finds recovered. There is usually little scope or requirement for a second stage of analysis or reporting (e.g. full analysis/publication reporting (Type 3)). 

These reports tend to be quite brief and outline basic information only including a quantification of the assemblage, identification of the finds to type and date, where possible. Contextual information will be included but no detailed distributional analysis will be undertaken. Typically, no discussion of significance and potential or recommendations for further work provided but recommendations for retention/discard of the finds is included.

Assessment Reports (Type 2)

Assessment reports provide an initial overview of an assemblage of finds and all finds will be inventoried. These reports include a quantification and characterisation of the assemblage, a discussion of their significance and potential, and sets out recommendations for further work and full specialist reporting (full analysis/publication report (Type 3)), if necessary. Where available, project research questions will be considered and discussed in relation to the significance and potential of the assemblage, as will relevant regional research frameworks.

The assessment process refines the available approaches to the full study of large and/or significant assemblages and allows a targeted strategy to be designed to analyse key objects to their full potential.  Where further work is required, recommendations will be made accordingly. These can include recommended approaches for targeted scientific analysis, further examination and more detailed recording, research, publication, illustration, conservation and retention of finds.

Not all assemblages require a further stage of analysis and reporting beyond assessment but this is often not possible to determine without conducting an assessment first.

This form of reporting is a necessary step in the post-excavation process for most commercial mitigation excavation projects in England and can be particularly useful for large assemblages.

Full Analysis/Publication Reports (Type 3)

Full analysis reporting can follow on from and build on the recommendations outlined in an initial Assessment Report (see above) or follow a Post-Excavation Research Design. For more information on what a Post-Excavation Research Design is, please click here.

Full analysis artefact reports are intended to provide a detailed and targeted analysis and discussion of the finds, accompanied by a catalogue. Where an earlier assessment has recommended further detailed examination and cataloguing of selected finds (for example, following conservation treatment), this will be undertaken at this stage to provide a closer identification of the object type and date, and to update the catalogue provided during assessment. Within the report significant individual artefacts or groups of artefacts will be highlighted, alongside a discussion of their form, date and on-site distribution. The report will also consider any dating evidence (e.g. AMS C14 radiocarbon dates) and results of scientific analyses undertaken on the objects as part of the post-excavation programme, and will discuss the finds within their wider context by drawing on relevant parallels and comparanda (e.g. local/regional/national), where appropriate.

For examples of my published specialist reports, please see my publications list.

Other services

To find out about the other services I offer, please see Services